Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products Research Articles

Implementing the EU HTA regulation: Insights from semi-structured interviews on patient expectations, Belgian and European institutional perspectives, and industry outlooks

Introduction: The goal of the Health Technology Assessment (HTA) Regulation 2021/2282 is to establish a more harmonized HTA framework, fostering member states cooperation and enabling equal patient access to innovative health technologies in Europe. This research aimed to assess the impact of the regulation on national HTAs, the strategic implications for health technology developers, and its influence on price and reimbursement negotiations.Methods: A scoping literature review encompassing peer-reviewed literature as well as grey literature was conducted. Between February and March 2023, semi-structured interviews (n = 20) were performed with stakeholders from Belgian governmental institutions, European institutions, advanced therapy medicinal product developers, academics, and sickness funds. The interviews were analyzed using the framework analysis method.Results: Numerous steps, such as the development of implementing acts and procedural guidelines remain to be taken. At member state level, national/regional HTA bodies and payers must act to adopt the new concepts of Joint Scientific Consultations (JSC) and Joint Clinical Assessments (JCA) within their national legislation, as well as revise their timelines and prepare for interactions at a European level. Compiling a harmonized PICO (Population, Intervention, Comparator, and Outcome), adapting local procedures, and increasing capacity to actively take part in the JSC and JCA are seen as primary barriers by several stakeholders. Training and education will help HTA bodies, payers, and health technology developers to participate in the European processes.Conclusion: While practical and legal challenges were identified, recommendations (such as actively preparing for the upcoming changes and increasing capacity while providing training) were provided to adapt national and European procedures to the needs of the HTA Regulation 2021/2282. The importance of fostering collaborations and aligning local HTA procedures with the new way of working set out by the Regulation was demonstrated with this study.

Novel drugs approved by the EMA, the FDA, and the MHRA in 2023: A year in review.

In 2023, seventy novel drugs received market authorization for the first time in either Europe (by the EMA and the MHRA) or in the United States (by the FDA). Confirming a steady recent trend, more than half of these drugs target rare diseases or intractable forms of cancer. Thirty drugs are categorized as "first-in-class" (FIC), illustrating the quality of research and innovation that drives new chemical entity discovery and development. We succinctly describe the mechanism of action of most of these FIC drugs and discuss the therapeutic areas covered, as well as the chemical category to which these drugs belong. The 2023 novel drug list also demonstrates an unabated emphasis on polypeptides (recombinant proteins and antibodies), Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products (gene and cell therapies) and RNA therapeutics, including the first-ever approval of a CRISPR-Cas9-based gene-editing cell therapy.

Assessing biologic/toxicologic effects of extractables from plastic contact materials for advanced therapy manufacturing using cell painting assay and cytotoxicity screening

Plastic components are essential in the pharmaceutical industry, encompassing container closure systems, laboratory handling equipment, and single-use systems. As part of their material qualification process, studies on interactions between plastic contact materials and process solutions or drug products are conducted. The assessment of single-use systems includes their potential impact on patient safety, product quality, and process performance. This is particularly crucial in cell and gene therapy applications since interactions with the plastic contact material may result in an adverse effect on the isolated therapeutic human cells. We utilized the cell painting assay (CPA), a non-targeted method, for profiling the morphological characteristics of U2OS human osteosarcoma cells in contact with chemicals related to plastic contact materials. Specifically, we conducted a comprehensive analysis of 45 common plastic extractables, and two extracts from single-use systems. Results of the CPA are compared with a standard cytotoxicity assay, an osteogenesis differentiation assay, and in silico toxicity predictions. The findings of this feasibility study demonstrate that the device extracts and most of the tested compounds do not evoke any measurable biological changes on the cells (induction  ≤ 5%) among the 579 cell features measured at concentrations  ≤ 50 µM. CPA can serve as an important assay to reveal unique information not accessible through quantitative structure–activity relationship analysis and vice versa. The results highlight the need for a combination of in vitro and in silico methods in a comprehensive assessment of single-use equipment utilized in advanced therapy medicinal products manufacturing.

Preclinical toxicity analyses of lentiviral vectors expressing the HIV-1 LTR-specific designer-recombinase Brec1.

Drug-based antiretroviral therapies (ART) efficiently suppress HIV replication in humans, but the virus persists as integrated proviral reservoirs in small numbers of cells. Importantly, ART cannot eliminate HIV from an infected individual, since it does not target the integrated provirus. Therefore, genome editing-based strategies that can inactivate or excise HIV genomes would provide the technology for novel curative therapies. In fact, the HIV-1 LTR-specific designer-recombinase Brec1 has been shown to remove integrated proviruses from infected cells and is highly efficacious on clinical HIV-1 isolates in vitro and in vivo, suggesting that Brec1 has the potential for clinical development of advanced HIV-1 eradication strategies in people living with HIV. In line with the preparation of a first-in-human advanced therapy medicinal product gene therapy trial, we here present an extensive preclinical evaluation of Brec1 and lentiviral vectors expressing the Brec1 transgene. This included detailed functional analysis of potential genomic off-target sites, assessing vector safety by investigating vector copy number (VCN) and the risk for potential vector-related insertional mutagenesis, as well as analyzing the potential of Brec1 to trigger an undesired strong T cell immune response. In conclusion, the antiviral designer-recombinase Brec1 is shown to lack any detectable cytopathic, genotoxic or T cell-related immunogenic effects, thereby meeting an important precondition for clinical application of the therapeutic lentiviral vector LV-Brec1 in novel HIV-1 curative strategies.

Challenges and opportunities for access to Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products in Brazil

IntroductionThe marketing authorization of Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products (ATMPs) in Brazil is recent. The features of these therapies impose specialized regulatory action and are consequently challenging for developers. The goal of this study was to identify the industry's experience in clinical development, marketing authorization and access to ATMPs through the Unified Health System (SUS, acronym in Portuguese), from a regulatory perspective. MethodsA survey containing structured questions was conducted among research participants who work at companies that commercialize ATMPs. A descriptive analysis was performed. ResultsWe invited 15 foreign pharmaceutical companies, of which 10 agreed to participate. Overall, participants assessed that Brazil has a well-established regulatory system, especially the sanitary registration by the National Health Surveillance Agency (Anvisa), which ensures the quality, safety, and efficacy of the products. The Agency's good interaction with the regulated sector, the harmonization of sanitary and ethical assessment systems with other countries, and the analysis time in the biosafety assessment of Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs) stand out as positive in industry's evaluation. On the other hand, it is important to advance the pricing regulation for these products since Brazilian regulations do not establish specific criteria for ATMP. One of the biggest challenges is the difficulty for the SUS in reimbursing these very high-cost therapies, especially using current Health Technology Assessment (HTA) methods. Conclusions and RecommendationsConsidering the increasing number of approvals of cell and gene therapies in Brazil in the coming years, a close dialogue between the industry and the public sector is recommended to advance regulatory improvements (pricing and HTA). Additionally, the construction of policies to promote the national Health Economic-Industrial Complex, based on a mission-oriented vision that encourages innovative models of financing, especially those that consider risk-sharing and co-financing technologies, will help provide the population with universal, equitable and sustainable access to ATMP in the SUS.

Advanced-Therapy Medicinal Products: Challenges for Implementation in Pediatric Clinical Practice

The article discusses classifications of medicines for gene and cell therapy. Data on medicinal products registered in Russia, as well as in the European Union countries, Great Britain, USA, and Japan is presented. The limitations on using such medicinal products were considered, including their high utilitarian cost and high risk of adverse events. The potential for increasing clinical efficacy and economic feasibility of advanced therapies (pediatrics included) has been analyzed.

Remuneration of donors for cell and gene therapies: an update on the principles and perspective of the World Marrow Donor Association.

The cell and gene therapy (CGT) sector has witnessed significant advancement over the past decade, the inception of advanced therapy medicinal products (ATMPs) being one of the most transformational. ATMPs treat serious medical conditions, in some cases providing curative therapy for seriously ill patients. There is interest in pivoting the ATMP development from autologous based treatments to allogenic, to offer faster and greater patient access that should ultimately reduce treatment costs. Consequently, starting material from allogenic donors is required, igniting ethical issues associated with financial gains and donor remuneration within CGT. The World Marrow Donor Association (WMDA) established the Cellular Therapy Committee to identify the role WMDA can play in safeguarding donors and patients in the CGT field. Here we review key ethical principles in relation to donating cellular material for the CGT field. We present the updated statement from WMDA on donor remuneration, which supports non-remuneration as the best way to ensure the safety and well-being of donors and patients alike. This is in line with the fundamental objective of the WMDA to maintain the health and safety of volunteer donors while ensuring high-quality stem cell products are available for all patients. We acknowledge that the CGT field is evolving at a rapid pace and there will be a need to review this position as new practices and applications come to pass.

Implementation of mDoE‐methods to a microcarrier‐based expansion processes for mesenchymal stem cells

AbstractThe need for advanced therapy medicinal products (ATMPs) has gained increased attention in recent years. In this respect, a well‐designed cell expansion process is needed to efficiently manufacture the required number of cells with the desired product quality. This step is challenging due to the biological complexity of the respective primary cell (e.g., mesenchymal stem cells (MSC)) and the usage of microcarrier‐based expansion systems. One accelerating approach for process design is model‐assisted Design of Experiments (mDoE) combining mathematical process models and statistical tools. In this study, the mDoE workflow was used for the development of an expansion processes with human immortalized mesenchymal stem cells (hMSC‐TERT) and the aim of maximizing cell yield assuming only a limited amount of prior knowledge at a very early stage of development. First, suitable microcarriers for expansion in shake flasks were screened and the differentiation of the cells was proven. Second, initial experiments were performed to generate prior knowledge, which was then used to set up the mathematical model and to estimate the model parameters. Finally, the mDoE was used to determine and evaluate the design space to be performed experimentally. Overall, a cell expansion process using microcarriers in a shake flask culture was successfully implemented and a significant increase in cell yield (up to 6,2‐fold) was achieved compared to literature.

Integrating Artificial Intelligence for Academic Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products: Challenges and Opportunities

Cell and gene therapies represent promising new treatment options for many diseases, but also face challenges for clinical translation and delivery. Hospital-based GMP facilities enable rapid bench-to-bedside development and patient access but require significant adaptation to implement pharmaceutical manufacturing in healthcare infrastructures constrained by space, regulations, and resources. This article reviews key considerations, constraints, and solutions for establishing hospital facilities for advanced therapy medicinal products (ATMPs). Technologies like process analytical technology (PAT), continuous manufacturing, and artificial intelligence (AI) can aid these facilities through enhanced process monitoring, control, and automation. However, quality systems tailored for product quality rather than just compliance, and substantial investment in infrastructure, equipment, personnel, and multi-departmental coordination, remain crucial for successful hospital ATMP facilities and to drive new therapies from research to clinical impact.

The expanding role of blood and tissue establishments in the development of advanced therapy medicinal products

Background aimsThe relationship between blood establishments and advanced cellular therapies is evident in several European countries, with some involved in research and development and/or in manufacturing. The aim of the present study was to understand the advanced therapy medicinal product (ATMP) infrastructural, regulatory and logistic requirements needed for the Irish Blood Transfusion Service to support advanced therapeutics in Ireland. MethodsAn online survey consisting of 13 questions was distributed in a targeted manner to the identified ATMP stakeholders in Ireland, namely those working in industry, health care, regulatory agencies or education. Subject matter experts in the field were approached and interviewed to gain further insight into the relationship between blood and tissue establishments (BTEs) and ATMPs, to explore the advantages these institutions have in development and to highlight potential challenges for implementation. ResultsIn total, 84.9% of survey respondents stated that BTEs have a role in the development of advanced therapeutics. Key BTE services identified as applicable to the ATMP sector from both surveys and interviews include the provision of starting materials for research and manufacturing, donor management, use of existing quality and traceability frameworks, product logistic strategies and Good Manufacturing Practice. Challenges for BTE expansion into the sector currently include high costs associated with ATMPs, lack of expertise in these therapies, limited therapeutic populations and no national ATMP strategic plan for Ireland. ConclusionsBlood establishments have services and expertise that can be extended into the advanced therapy sector. The existing knowledge and skill base of BTEs in Ireland should be leveraged to accelerate the development of ATMP strategies for industry and healthcare.

Chimeric Antigen Receptor-T (CAR-T) Cells as “Living Drugs”: A Clinical Pharmacist Perspective

Background. Chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cell therapy, a “living drug” immunotherapy, harnesses the power of T-cells from a patient (autologous) or healthy donor (allogeneic) to target and kill cancer cells and has shown unprecedented outcomes in patients with relapsed and refractory malignancies. Treatment with CAR-T cells requires the application of unique skillsets in recognised specialist centres for successful outcomes and requires management by the multidisciplinary team incorporating the specialist pharmacist. Method. A multimodal research strategy was employed for this literature review whereby PubMed, Google Scholar, Embase, Stella Library Search, EMA website, and EBMT website were sources of information. The search was limited from 2020 onwards with key terms referring to CAR-T cell therapy. Results and Discussion. There are six CAR-T cell products currently approved by the European Medicines Agency (EMA) and Food and Drug Administration (FDA) which target haematological malignancies with abundant clinical trials underway exploring new and improved CAR designs and antigen targets. As CAR-T cell therapy is an advanced therapy medicinal product (ATMP), there is need for an extensive regulatory framework underpinning its safety and efficacy. The clinical pharmacist plays an integral role in the provision of safe and effective CAR-T cell therapy including governance, operational and clinical aspects of treatment. Pharmacists may also be involved through provision of “Qualified Person” (QP) expertise in clinical trials and for release within hospitals under certain circumstances. There is a need for harmonised and accessible guidance on the clinical delivery of ATMPs such as CAR-T cells, with fully delineated responsibilities of pharmacists involving the oversight and supervision of CAR-T cell treatment. Conclusion. There is an unmet need to provide suitable and applicable literature for clinical pharmacists who are involved in the delivery of CAR-T cells. We have provided an overview of T-cell biology and an explanation of CAR-T cell design and the biomanufacturing process. We reviewed the complex and multifaceted treatment cycle requiring considerable logistics, and described the involvement of the clinical pharmacist in each part of this cycle from patient selection to postinfusion care. Finally, we look to the challenges and future opportunities that will require the involvement of the clinical pharmacist.

What are the Changes in 2023 for Access to Advanced Therapy Medicinal Products (ATMPs) in France?

ATMPs are the most expensive innovative treatments, thus they require special regulation. Past regulatory measures in France, such as limiting the growth of drug expenditures, the creation of a fund to finance pharmaceutical innovation, the use of performance-based contracts and greater emphasis on medico-economic evaluations in pricing have been contributing to having both universal access to innovative therapies and fair remuneration for innovation. The importance of transparency, public participation in healthcare evaluation, and the challenges of setting drug prices based on their value are not negligible either. Although further negotiations are still necessary to ensure equitable access to medicines and control rising healthcare costs, France has made pioneering steps recently which would be worthy to follow for other states. The Social Security Financing Act for 2023 introduces measures to control face prices, offers a new funding model, and encourages manufacturers to submit reimbursement claims for the full scope of marketing authorizations.

Optimization and Validation of a Harmonized Protocol for Generating Therapeutic-Grade Dendritic Cells in a Randomized Phase II Clinical Trial, Using Two Varied Antigenic Sources.

Autologous dendritic cell (DC)-based immunotherapy is a cell-based advanced therapy medicinal product (ATMP) that was first introduced more than three decades ago. In the current study, our objective was to establish a harmonized protocol using two varied antigenic sources and a good manufacturing practice (GMP)-compliant, manual method for generating clinical-grade DCs at a limited-resource academic setting. After obtaining ethical committee-approved informed consent, the recruited patients underwent leukapheresis, and single-batch DC production was carried out. Using responder-independent flow cytometric assays as quality control (QC) criteria, we propose a differentiation and maturation index (DI and MI, respectively), calculated with the QC cut-off and actual scores of each batch for comparison. Changes during cryopreservation and personnel variation were assessed periodically for up to two to three years. Using our harmonized batch production protocol, the average DI was 1.39 and MI was 1.25. Allogenic responder proliferation was observed in all patients, while IFN-gamma secretion, evaluated using flow cytometry, was detected in 10/36 patients and significantly correlated with CD8+ T cell proliferation (p value-0.0002). Tracking the viability and phenotype of cryopreserved MDCs showed a >90% viability for up to three years, while a mature DC phenotype was retained for up to one year. Our results confirm that the manual/semi-automated protocol was simple, consistent, and cost-effective, without the requirement for expensive equipment and without compromising on the quality of the final product.

Optimal Therapeutic Strategy of Bone Marrow-Originated Autologous Mesenchymal Stromal/Stem Cells for ALS.

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is characterized by selective and progressive neurodegenerative changes in motor neural networks. Given the system complexity, including anatomically distributed sites of degeneration from the motor cortex to the spinal cord and chronic pro-inflammatory conditions, a cell-based therapeutic strategy could be an alternative approach to treating ALS. Lessons from previous mesenchymal stromal/stem cell (MSC) trials in ALS realized the importance of 3 aspects in current and future MSC therapy, including the preparation of MSCs, administration routes and methods, and recipient-related factors. This review briefly describes the current status and future prerequisites for an optimal strategy using bone-marrow-originated MSCs to treat ALS. We suggest mandatory factors in the optimized therapeutic strategy focused on advanced therapy medicinal products produced according to Good Manufacturing Practice, an optimal administration method, the selection of proper patients, and the importance of biomarkers.

Using automated text classification to explore uncertainty in NICE appraisals for drugs for rare diseases.

This study examined the application, feasibility, and validity of supervised learning models for text classification in appraisals for rare disease treatments (RDTs) in relation to uncertainty, and analyzed differences between appraisals based on the classification results. We analyzed appraisals for RDTs (n=94) published by the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) between January 2011 and May 2023. We used Naïve Bayes, Lasso, and Support Vector Machine models in a binary text classification task (classifying paragraphs as either referencing uncertainty in the evidence base or not). To illustrate the results, we tested hypotheses in relation to the appraisal guidance, advanced therapy medicinal product (ATMP) status, disease area, and age group. The best performing (Lasso) model achieved 83.6 percent classification accuracy (sensitivity=74.4 percent, specificity=92.6 percent). Paragraphs classified as referencing uncertainty were significantly more likely to arise in highly specialized technology (HST) appraisals compared to appraisals from the technology appraisal (TA) guidance (adjusted odds ratio=1.44, 95 percent CI 1.09, 1.90, p=0.004). There was no significant association between paragraphs classified as referencing uncertainty and appraisals for ATMPs, non-oncology RDTs, and RDTs indicated for children only or adults and children. These results were robust to the threshold value used for classifying paragraphs but were sensitive to the choice of classification model. Using supervised learning models for text classification in NICE appraisals for RDTs is feasible, but the results of downstream analyses may be sensitive to the choice of classification model.

Proceedings of the 2023 Viral Clearance Symposium: 2023 VCS Summary, Pending Questions, and Next Steps.

The 2023 Viral Clearance Symposium (VCS) was hosted by Takeda on 24 and 25 May 2023 in Vienna, Austria. The present conference extended the structure of the previous biennial symposia held between 2009 and 2019. As recapitulated in the introductory session, the genesis of the VCS, as described in the Proceedings of the 2009 VCS was "the worldwide regulatory and industry recognition that challenges, gaps, and opportunities exist, that it formally addressed could benefit the field as whole." This report provides a synopsis of the progress achieved at the conference resulting from detailed technical discussions and the pending questions that still require attention to address. The 2023 VCS was composed of nine individual sessions of short presentations followed by in-depth panel discussions from the presenters. Sessions included Regulatory Updates (with a focus on ICH Q5A(R2) efforts), including a summary of lessons learned from the 2019 VCS, and progress on these key areas mapped into 2023 VCS topics: Viral Clearance Strategy and Case Studies, New Modalities in Chromatography and Adsorptive Filters, Continuous Processing, Viral Clearance Strategy and Process Understanding, Virus Inactivation, Upstream and Downstream Virus Retentive Filtration and Cell Banks, and Advanced Technologies (advanced therapy medicinal products, next-generation sequencing).

Mitochondria and vision – a life in mitochondria always on the move

Mitochondrial disease is among the most common form of inherited neurological disorder, with a minimum prevalence of 1:5000 and few if any effective treatments or cures. Mitochondria are highly dynamic organelles undergoing coordinated cycles of fission and fusion, referred as ‘mitochondrial dynamics’, in order to maintain their shape, distribution and size. Mitochondrial dysfunction is seen in numerous diseases, including rare primary genetic mitochondrial diseases, many affecting the eye and vision and various common degenerative disorders. Mitochondrial dysfunction is implicated in the ageing process and also contributes to ischaemic cardiac disease and cancer. Mitochondrial dysfunction has been well documented in neurodegenerative diseases, such as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, Alzheimer's disease, Parkinson's disease, glaucoma and age‐related macular degeneration. Consequently, it is now becoming a major target for new therapeutic development. To date, however, there have been few if any successes. The problems faced in addressing mitochondrial dysfunction range from identifying suitable targets to lack of methods that reliably transfect mitochondria. There may be huge potential in taking an advanced therapy medicinal products (ATMPs) approach, developing medicines for human use that are based on genes, tissues or cells. A novel approach in the literature is the transplantation of fully functional mitochondria directly into defective cells. Could this be the more generic solution that would address the diverse range of mitochondrial defects in disease?

Cell Therapy of Vascular and Neuropathic Complications of Diabetes: Can We Avoid Limb Amputation?

Globally, a leg is amputated approximately every 30 seconds, with an estimated 85 percent of these amputations being attributed to complications arising from diabetic foot ulcers (DFU), as stated by the American Diabetes Association. Peripheral arterial disease (PAD) is a risk factor resulting in DFU and can, either independently or in conjunction with diabetes, lead to recurring, slow-healing ulcers and amputations. According to guidelines amputation is the recommended treatment for patients with no-option critical ischemia of the limb (CTLI). In this article we propose cell therapy as an alternative strategy for those patients. We also suggest the optimal time-frame for an effective therapy, such as implanting autologous mononuclear cells (MNCs), autologous and allogeneic mesenchymal stromal cells (MSC) as these treatments induce neuropathy relief, regeneration of the blood vessels and tissues, with accelerated ulcer healing, with no serious side effects, proving that advanced therapy medicinal product (ATMPs) application is safe and effective and, hence, can significantly prevent limb amputation.

Generation of a bank of clinical-grade, HLA-homozygous iPSC lines with high coverage of the Spanish population

BackgroundInduced pluripotent stem cell (iPSC)-derived cell therapies are an interesting new area in the field of regenerative medicine. One of the approaches to decrease the costs of iPSC-derived therapies is the use of allogenic homozygous human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-matched donors to generate iPSC lines and to build a clinical-grade iPSC bank covering a high percentage of the Spanish population.MethodsThe Spanish Stem Cell Transplantation Registry was screened for cord blood units (CBUs) homozygous for the most common HLA-A, HLA-B and HLA-DRB1 haplotypes. Seven donors were selected with haplotypes covering 21.37% of the haplotypes of the Spanish population. CD34-positive hematopoietic progenitors were isolated from the mononuclear cell fraction of frozen cord blood units from each donor by density gradient centrifugation and further by immune magnetic labeling and separation using purification columns. Purified CD34 + cells were reprogrammed to iPSCs by transduction with the CTS CytoTune-iPS 2.1 Sendai Reprogramming Kit.ResultsThe iPSCs generated from the 7 donors were expanded, characterized, banked and registered. Master cell banks (MCBs) and working cell banks (WCBs) from the iPSCs of each donor were produced under GMP conditions in qualified clean rooms.ConclusionsHere, we present the first clinical-grade, iPSC haplobank in Spain made from CD34 + cells from seven cord blood units homozygous for the most common HLA-A, HLA-B and HLA-DRB1 haplotypes within the Spanish population. We describe their generation by transduction with Sendai viral vectors and their GMP-compliant expansion and banking. These haplolines will constitute starting materials for advanced therapy medicinal product development (ATMP).

Medical Writing explores the many faces of biotechnology

This Medical Writing issue focuses on the crucial role of medical writing and communications in biotechnology and product development in healthcare. In the pharmaceutical and medical device industries, biotechnology uses biological systems and living organisms in R&D and production processes for product development. Some biotechnologies include biologic and biosimilar pharmaceuticals, vaccines, and advanced therapy medicinal products, including gene and cell therapies and tissue engineered products.